Security theatre

This summer, I had to get on a plane for only the second time since 9/11 — and the first time without using prescription medication. There was no other reasonable way for us to get Jack to DisneyWorld®, and sometimes you gotta do what you gotta do. But I was not sanguine about it, and friends asked me why.

"You know it's safe," people would say, "You used to fly all the time." And it's true; in the late '90s, I was a Platinum-level business traveler, 50K miles a year. I actually understood, on a fundamental level, why "wake me up for meals," in Warren Zevon's "Mr. Bad Example" was such a grimly funny world-weary metonymy: ask a trans-Pacific traveler who once round-tripped to Tokyo for a 3-hour meeting. But that was all before.

Then, there is a blank gap. Planes scream by in telephoto shots; there is smoke, buildings fall.

After September 11, the Bush Administration, prodded into bureaucratic action, nationalized transportation screening and proclaimed the system secure. The reports of people sneaking through all manner of contraband either accidentally or as deliberate tests, aberrations. The appearance of infants and the president of Bolivia on the vaunted "no-fly" list, statistical noise. All is well.

Jeffrey Goldberg, in a delightful piece in this month's Atlantic, describes the total failure of what the pros call "security theatre," an airport screening process designed to create a highly visible illusion of safety.

On another occasion, at LaGuardia, in New York, the transportation-security officer in charge of my secondary screening emptied my carry-on bag of nearly everything it contained, including a yellow, three-foot-by-four-foot Hezbollah flag, purchased at a Hezbollah gift shop in south Lebanon. The flag features, as its charming main image, an upraised fist clutching an AK-47 automatic rifle. Atop the rifle is a line of Arabic writing that reads THEN SURELY THE PARTY OF GOD ARE THEY WHO WILL BE TRIUMPHANT. The officer took the flag and spread it out on the inspection table. She finished her inspection, gave me back my flag, and told me I could go. I said, “That’s a Hezbollah flag.” She said, “Uh-huh.” Not “Uh-huh, I’ve been trained to recognize the symbols of anti-American terror groups, but after careful inspection of your physical person, your behavior, and your last name, I’ve come to the conclusion that you are not a Bekaa Valley–trained threat to the United States commercial aviation system,” but “Uh-huh, I’m going on break, why are you talking to me?”
— Via the Atlantic

Here's my modest proposal. They should make it an actual theatrical experience. Dim all the lights, throw up a mirror ball, and give each traveler a pin spot and hand mike. From the moment you take off your shoes, you must boogie to the magnetometer while doing a karaoke version of "I Will Survive." Think about it, Mandrake. Have you ever seen a terrorist do The Chicken Dance?

But I digress.

Want to keep up with this stuff? I read Bruce Schneier on Security.

Comments

Once, a long time ago, I was at Heathrow in a long line of people waiting to go through the metal detector at the airport screening area. This was an additional screen area past the luggage x-ray area. On the other side of the detector was a security person with one of those hand-held wands and was singling out some people for closer screening while other people he waved on past.

I had nothing to do in line but watch, so I tried to see if there was a pattern to who he was screening and who he was waving past.

Parents with little kids, elderly women, and people who generally looked like they didn't know where they were supposed to be going he waved past.

People he stopped -- men, young to early middle age, reasonably well dressed, most with some growth of beard even if only a couple of days worth, who looked like they knew where they were going and what they were doing and most of them carrying briefcases.

In other words, people who looked like me. So, I took my sport jacket off and rumpled it over my arm. Instead of carrying my briefcase normally, I clutched it clumsily. I took my passport out and held it in my hand. I then kept my mouth somewhat slack-open, looked around and about confusedly and generally tried to look as lost as I could.

He waved me on past. At Heathrow. Where there have actually been terrorist attacks.

Oh yeah, I feel real safe.